

We took the guesswork out of this for you, because every one of the winners on our best eyeliners list is waterproof (or water resistant, meaning it can still move a bit if it were to come in contact with water). “Gel eyeliner offers the most vivid coverage, while a pencil eyeliner could be as sheer as you'd like it to be.” If you're looking for a sharp cat eye, a liquid liner with a felt tip is your best bet, whereas a pencil is better for a smudgy effect. “Each provides slightly different coverage,” she explains. Things to Consider Before Buying Eyeliner Formulaīychkova notes that there are five main eyeliner types: gel, pencil, liquid, powder, and felt-tip. Type: Water-resistant liquid | Colors: 2 | Features: Ultra-thin applicator | Size: 0.55 mL It did take some time to remove the eyeliner, especially the thicker line on the top lid, but that didn’t stop our tester from giving the Fenty Flyliner high-flying scores.
#GREEN EYE LINER SKIN#
It dried instantly with no transfer, according to our tester, who has oily skin and tried this out in the summertime. The tester found the black to have excellent pigment that required no reapplication to get the dark look she was going for. And the product lives up to its name-our tester found that it had a very light feel to it that didn’t make her eyes feel weighed down by the product.Ĭreating a cat eye and lining the bottom of the eye were both a cinch. The "flex tip" helps you precisely apply the sleek, water-resistant formula with ease, due in part also to the "easy grip" triangle shape of the pen. Kudos to the ultra-thin applicator wand on this Fenty Beauty Flyliner. Keep reading to learn more about the best eyeliners PEOPLE tested, and how we tested them.Īpplicator might be too thin for some looks They also rated these eyeliners based on ease of removal, which is important, considering that all of the winners on our best eyeliners list are waterproof. They chose winners based on those eyeliners that offered the best in terms of application, pigmentation, dry time, and wear. Our PEOPLE Tested team went from barefaced to glam by testing a wide selection of liquid, gel, and pencil eyeliners. If you like the ease of application that a felt-tip eyeliner provides, get ready for a “bold and dramatic crisp line.” Looking for an eyeliner that gives you the ability to build color and smudge or blend to your heart’s content? Pencil eyeliners will help you achieve that, she says.

“Gel eyeliner offers a vinyl-like finish it's typically glossy and vivid,” Bychkova says. Want all eyes on yours when you walk in the room? Try a gel liner. (Spoiler alert: Our testers found several, so keep scrolling.) For example, liquid eyeliner can be "crisp and dramatic" if you find the right formula, she explains. When it comes to choosing the best eyeliner for your needs, “Decide on the finish you are going for,” says Katya Bychkova, beauty expert and founder of the blog Style Sprinter. Luckily for you, we’ve done the hard work of testing a number of them out to discover the best eyeliners for your makeup case.


Whether you like to stick with tried-and-true brands that have been around for decades or you’ve been eyeing products from the buzzy celebrity lines like Victoria Beckham Beauty and Rihanna’s Fenty Beauty, there are countless eyeliners in a variety of formulas and a rainbow of colors to choose from.
